North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: DSL restrictions for CLECs?

  • From: alex
  • Date: Mon Aug 25 21:45:10 2003

> I'm on a digital pair gain line out of a local RT. There are nothing but
> DPG lines run from the CO -- copper is not, and never was, an option for
> this neighborhood. SBC will not allow CLECs to access their DPG lines
> either in the CO or in the RT -- "use the copper" is the response.
> Is this standard practice? Is this legal? I am basically in a situation
> where DSL availability should be a non-issue, except that SBC/Yahoo! has
> constructed a scenario where they are the only possible provider due to
> their decision to replace copper pair with DPG, and to refuse to allow
> CLEC DSLAMs on the DPG lines.
a) Refusal to allow CLECs into RTs is not necessarily bad-intentioned.  
Some RTs are really nothing more than a tiny enclosure, where there's
really no space for much equipment.

b) As far as -legality- of refusing to permit CLECs into RTs, according
to latest Triennial Review Ruling (which came out only a week ago, and
hasn't been fully digested yet due to it being 527 pages), it appears that
ILECs -must- now permit CLECs into RTs where it is technologically
possible. (IANAL, and wording of the ruling isn't the clearest).

c) Even if CLECs were permitted in your RT, its far from the fact that any 
CLEC would want to be in there, due to cost/benefit considerations: RT 
serves a small number of lines. CLEC would need to pay for backhaul and 
rental of space, and considering that you probably would be the only 
customer in an average RT that serves 500-5000 lines, that wouldn't make 
financial sense.

d) Although not a part of Triennial Review (because it is not considered a 
UNE), ILECs are still obligated to offer access to their own DSLAMs to 
everyone equally, on the similar terms as their own Internet subsidiaries.
(I'm not sure where the requirement for that comes from though, TCA '96?) 

So, you can still get DSL service from your friendly neighbourhood ISP
which would use ILEC's DSLAM-in-RT.

Brave-hearted can always read the full text of triennial review at:

Alex Pilosov    | DSL, Colocation, Hosting Services
President 	| [email protected]    (800) 710-7031
Pilosoft, Inc.  |