n89-event-page-header-image-2500

Registration is open!

Submit a Talk Proposal

Learn More

Become a Sponsor

Learn More
n89-hex-simple-shadow-3

 

NANOG 89 San Diego

16-18 October 2023



IPv4-Global
HOST SPONSOR

Gather With Us

NANOG is, and always has been, dedicated to the people who make up our community. Our tri-annual meetings draw up to 1,500 individuals in multiple facets of network engineering, operations, and architecture, who gather in major cities across North America.

Stay Competitive

Stay ahead of the curve with direct access to the industry’s top minds + hours of peer-reviewed content.

Bring Your Ideas to Life

Presentations at NANOG spark the imagination, encourage dialog, and drive new solutions to our greatest networking challenges.

Make Meaningful Connections

We understand the importance of one-on-one appointments with your colleagues — we offer the tools you need to schedule meetups and network.

Premium Sponsors

AWS

PLATINUM

arin

PLATINUM

ciena

PLATINUM

equinix

PLATINUM

BlueCat

GOLD

Telstra

GOLD

Verisign

GOLD

keynote

Monday Keynote:

The Expanding Landscape of Internet Governance: Why Network Operators Need a Global View w/ President and CEO of ARIN, John Curran

Curran will review the Internet's ongoing evolution from a massive commercial activity to something more integral to society. Key topics will include how Internet coordination differs from governance, how the technical community has engaged in Internet governance, and the potential consequences network operators will experience as the landscape evolves.

Date: 16, Oct.
Time: 10:15 - 11:00 (PDT)

keynote

Tuesday Keynote:

Fireside Chat with Chief Operating Officer of Arista Networks, Anshul Sadana + NANOG Producer Elizabeth Drolet

Anshul Sadana, COO of Arista Networks, takes the stage for a fireside chat. Anshul will sit down with NANOG's Producer Elizabeth Drolet for a candid conversation where we will have the chance to get behind the scenes insight as they discuss both industry and personal stories, ideas, and thoughts. Get to know the man behind the tech and learn more about how to stay successful in today's rapidly changing environment.

Date: 17, Oct.
Time: 10:00 - 11:00 (PDT)

Registration is Open!

NANOG registration fees are in USD and include the following: access to general and breakout sessions, breakfast daily, lunch on the first two days of the event, entry to all social/networking events.

NANOG 89 Hotel Information

Headquarter Hotel
Loews Coronado Bay Resort

4000 Coronado Bay Road
Coronado, CA 92118

Peering Coordination Forum

Applications will remain open until 20 applications are received or 09 October 2023, whichever is first.
The forum provides time for attendees to meet and network with others in the peering community present at NANOG.


Coming to the NANOG 89 Stage in San Diego

The following presentations will take place while NANOG is in San Diego 16-18 October, 2023. More talks will be listed as the Program Committee accepts submissions.

Full Abstract

An ongoing issue with Internet standards development is limited interaction between the standards developers and the network operator community. This talk is a step toward bridging that gap, highlighting ongoing work from the IETF that is likely to be published in the RFC series or will otherwise have notable operational considerations.

David Lawrence: A veteran of the Usenet Wars
Full Abstract

In this session we review IPv6 features and capabilities on AWS, best practices for adopting IPv6 on AWS, and reference architectures. We also dive deeper into the common use cases that drive customer IPv6 adoption on AWS, and lessons learned to help you accelerate your IPv6 adoption journey.

Alexandra Huides: Alexandra Huides is a Principal Networking Specialist Solutions Architect within Strategic Accounts at Amazon Web Services. She focuses on helping customers build and develop networking architectures for highly scalable and resilient AWS environments. Alex is also a public speaker for AWS, and is helping customers adopt IPv6. Outside work, she loves sailing, especially catamarans, traveling, discovering new cultures, and reading.
Full Abstract

What if you could fully automate your internet exchange? You can! In this presentation, IX founders Chris Grundemann and Matt "Grizz" Griswold will walk through the thinking, the architecture, the tools, and a real example to show you how-to use modern, open-source tools to build an IX operations platform capable of setting your IX to FullAuto.

We will cover the terms and definitions that need to be understood, we'll introduce the network automation philosophy that drives successful projects, and cover the core principles that facilitate excellent execution. Then we'll walk you through an example, using a real IX (IX-Denver), to demonstrate the possibilities - and provide a roadmap for everyone else who wants to do the same.

Automation is not just for network operators. We can, and should, automate our internet exchanges as well. Let's go!

Chris Grundemann: Chris Grundemann is a passionate, creative technologist and a strong believer in technology's power to aid in the betterment of humankind. In his current role as Managing Director at Grundemann Technology Solutions he is expressing that passion by helping technology businesses grow and by helping any business grow with technology. Chris has been using technology, marketing, and strategy to build businesses and non-profit organizations for two decades. He holds 8 patents in network technology and is the author of two books, an IETF RFC, a personal weblog, and a multitude of industry papers, articles, and posts. He is a co-founder and Chief Executive Officer (CEO) for FullCtl, the interconnection automation company; as well as a co-founder of the Network Automation Forum, the organization behind the AutoCon series of events. Chris is the creator and co-host of The Imposter Syndrome Network Podcast, focused on encouraging the next generation of digital infrastructure engineers. He is also a co-founder, Director, and Chair Emeritus of IX-West and the Chair of the Board of Directors of OIX, the global data center and interconnection standards body. He has held previous volunteer positions with CO ISOC (which he founded), ISOC-NY (Vice President), ARIN, NANOG, SANOG, AfPIF, CEA, UPnP, DLNA, RMv6TF, and several others. Chris has given presentations in 34 countries on 5 continents and is often sought out to speak at conferences, NOGs, and NOFs the world over. Currently based in West Texas, Chris can be reached via his website at chrisgrundemann.com.
Full Abstract

RPKI ROV adoption has grown significantly over the past five years. In a recent milestone, the percentage of IPv4 routes in the global routing table with ROAs has finally crossed 50% (IPv6 crossed this mark last year). In addition, another major telecom began rejecting RPKI-invalid routes reducing the propagation of these problematic routes even farther.

Finally, this talk with present an analysis of the 'effective expirations' of ROAs and how the behavior of these expirations varies greatly between RIRs due to differences in their cryptographic chains.

Doug Madory: Doug Madory is the Director of Internet Analysis for Kentik where he works on Internet infrastructure analysis. The Washington Post dubbed him “The Man who can see the Internet" for his reputation in identifying significant developments in the structure of the Internet. Doug is regularly quoted by major news outlets about developments ranging from national blackouts to BGP hijacks to the activation of submarine cables. Prior to Kentik, he was the lead analyst for Oracle's Internet Intelligence team (formerly Dyn Research and Renesys).
Full Abstract

When it comes to Internet access, Indigenous communities are among the most underserved throughout North America. According to Canada’s ISED, 97 percent of urban households have access to high-speed Internet, compared to only 37 percent in rural communities. The statistics are even more bleak for Indigenous communities, where just 24 percent have access to high-speed Internet.
The Internet Society works with Indigenous communities to find and implement sustainable solutions that meet their unique connectivity needs. Supporting communities to build and maintain local Internet infrastructure has proven to be key to connect the unconnected.
This talk will cover a recent partnership between the Internet Society and the National Research Council of Canada (NRC) that aimed at identifying and training a number of indigenous communities in Ontario and Northwest territories, in preparation for broadband network deployments.
Also, this talk will cover the successful deployment of a wireless broadband network in the indigenous community of Ulukhaktok in the Arctic, which would perhaps be the northern-most such deployment.

Dr. Hosein Badran: Dr. Hosein Badran holds the position of Senior Director, Internet Growth and Trust, with the Internet Society, based in Ottawa, Canada. He represents the Internet Society at the ITU-T standardization organization, particularly SG11, SG13 and SG17, and invited member of the Canadian ITU-T National Study Groups NSG11, NSG13 and NSG17. Special focus in the standardization work is on topics related to the evolution of the Internet - proposals potentially resulting in the fragmentation of the Internet, like NewIP and related proposals. He is a member of the North American Network Operators Group (NANOG) Education Committee, and the Canadian Forum for Digital Infrastructure Resilience (CFDIR), established by Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED). He is a co-author of the final report of the Canadian Multi-stakeholder Initiative on IoT Security: “Enhancing IoT Security: Final Outcomes and Recommendations”. He has been a member of the Steering Committee of the Arab IGF since its inception in 2010, overseeing the program content for the annual event, and was the Chair of the Program Committee of the Canadian IGF 2020. During his career of over 25 years as C-level expert, he spent 14 years with Cisco Systems as Distinguished Systems Architect and Regional Chief Technology Officer as a member of the Cisco CTO Office. Before joining the Internet Society, he spent three years as Director, Special Projects and Innovation, at Qatar Computing Research Institute (QCRI), a member of Qatar Foundation, in Doha, Qatar, where he led projects dealing with machine learning and data-driven optimization in different national socio-economic initiatives including smart transportation, e-health, aviation, and cybersecurity. He worked also with Nortel Networks in Ottawa, Canada, FORE Systems (now Ericsson) in Dubai, and Siemens AG in Munich, Germany. Dr. Badran holds a Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering from Queen’s University in Canada. https://www.linkedin.com/in/dr-hosein-f-badran-4b56941/
Full Abstract

Datacenters are comprised of thousands of servers, network and storage devices. Data Center Networks (DCNs) are the communications backbone of a datacenter. Several architectural and design innovations have been introduced in DCNs to address the growing size and increasing operational demands of the datacenter. From a protocol perspective, these demands and challenges have been addressed primarily by aggregating multiple off-the-shelf protocols and retrofitting them to the DCN communication needs. This aggregation has resulted in higher overhead, added operational complexity and requires increased effort to perform DCN troubleshooting and maintenance.
In this work we present a new protocol that leverages the structured and symmetrical DCN topology to significantly simplify DCN operations of routing, load balancing, fast failure detection and IP packet forwarding between the servers. We introduce the Multi-Root Meshed Tree Protocol (MR-MTP) which establishes routes without a routing protocol, performs load balancing, provisions fast failure recovery and forwards IP packets between servers. Testing was performed by adopting the folded-Clos topology. The performance of MR-MTP was compared to the popular protocol suite used in folded-Clos topology DCN, i.e. Border Gateway Protocol (BGP for routing), Equal Cost Multipath Protocol (ECMP for load balancing) and Bidirectional Forwarding Detection (BFD to speed up convergence).
As both TCP and UDP are required in folded-Clos (BGP requires TCP for its operation and BFD requires UDP), MR-MTP is replacing six protocols in a DCN router, i.e. BGP, TCP, ECMP, BFD, UDP and IP. MR-MTP is fully backwards-compatible to Internet Protocol (IP) and Ethernet. MR-MTP autoconfigures and auto-assigns routable addresses to the DCN routers, reducing the configuration needs. MR-MTP coded in C language was compared to the protocol suite BGP/ECMP/BFD (from frrouting.org) using folded clos topologies set up in the Fabric testbed (https://portal.fabric-testbed.net).
The results (provided in the slides) of these comparisons clearly demonstrate that significant performance improvement can be achieved with MR-MTP over BGP/ECMP/BFD. The testing evaluated convergence time, control overhead, packets lost, and blast radius on an interface failure. Given its unique approach, MR-MTP offers many other benefits including reduced hardware required to manufacture, immunity from traditional attacks against BGP, TCP and IP, reduced power consumption (and associated cooling costs) among others which will be investigated in the future.

Nirmala Shenoy: Dr. Nirmala Shenoy, received her Bachelors and Master’s in Engineering from Madras University, India. She worked as a Research Scientist in Central Electronics Engineering Research Institute in Chennai, India. She was recipient of the Deutscher Akademischer AustauschDienst, (DAAD) a German fellowship, during which period she received a PhD in Computer Science from University of Bremen, Germany. Dr. Shenoy taught at the Information Communication Institute of Singapore, a collaboration of AT & T Bell Labs US & National Computer Board, Singapore. She subsequently held teaching and research positions in Australian Universities, before joining Rochester Institute of technology, Rochester, New York as Professor in the ISchool, School of Information, Golisano College of Computing and Information Sciences. Her research focus is design, development and evaluation of clean slate protocol solutions to challenging networks problems.
Full Abstract

With a few simple changes, IP-transit customers can increase the reliability of the prefix filtering provided to them by their IP-transit providers, and hopefully avoid easy-to-mitigate prefix filtering issues.

As an IP-Transit provider, we (Inter.link) often encounter prefix list generation issues with our customer's IRR data. In this talk we'll present some easy to implement changes, in relation to their IRR data and PeeringDB data, that have helped our customers, which other IP-transit customers can implement to improve the quality of their service with their provider.

Full Abstract

This 15-minute talk introduces the audience to ICANN's KINDNS Initiative. Modeled on ISOC's MANRS program, KINDNS (which stands for Knowledge-sharing and Instantiating Norms for DNS and Naming Security) aims at developing a simple but effective framework for a secure DNS operation to which operators can voluntarily and easily commit. This framework should be something simple to refer to and be accessible to even small operators that may typically be unable to dedicate many resources to globally follow both the evolution of the DNS protocol and discussions about operational best practices.

Full Abstract

The American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) is a nonprofit, member-based organization that administers IP addresses and ASNs in support of the operation and growth of the Internet. Hear from ARIN's Chief Customer Officer on where the organization sits with IPv6 growth, IPv4 Waitlist and Transfer stats, along with other notable organizational updates.

Full Abstract

Network operators engineer their networks with enough capacity to service peak loads. They also engineer redundant capacity into their networks. During off-hours, much, if not most, of this capacity is unused.

Sadly, most networks consume nearly the same amount of power during off-hours as they consume during peak-hours.

In this presentation, we propose a power management portal that reports a) network status, b) network power utilization and c) network power efficiency. It also proposes strategies for powering down selected router components during off-hours and powers those router components up and down as per the proposed strategy.

This power management portal is under development and the authors are soliciting co-innovators.

Ronald Bonica: Ron Bonica is a Distinguished Engineer at Juniper Networks, specializing in IPv6 and Segment Routing. He is active in the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), having authored or co-authored twenty RFC documents and served three two-year terms as co-director of the IETF Operations and Management Area. Ron currently co-chairs the IETF V6OPS and OPSEC Working Groups. Prior to joining Juniper Networks, Ron was employed by a major Internet Service Provider and operated an Layer 3 Virtual Private Network for U.S. Government customers.
Full Abstract

The use of IP spoofing for generating DDoS attacks has been around for decades. In the last several years, tracing back spoofed traffic and engaging networks to deploy ACLs/uRPF to enforce BCP38 has become a common method to disrupt DDoS-As-A-Service providers (also known as booters/stressers). This presentation will cover the overall effort along with methodologies that networks can use to detect this as well as controls they can implement to mitigate this behavior. A number of real-world trace back scenarios will be covered as well as interesting things found along the way.

Full Abstract

This talk summarises for a NANOG audience an academic paper recently presented at the "23rd Workshop on the Economics of Information Security". In the paper we evaluate a rare successful intervention in the management of Internet infrastructure -– a multi-year "traceback" campaign to shut down sources of spoofed traffic utilised for DDoS attacks. We assess why it has been possible to "move the needle" on an issue that has dogged the network engineering community for more than thirty years. The decentralised community of competing network providers has few incentives to solve the issue -- which is why little has changed since the flurry of activity when BCP38 (and the century) was new. Our analysis is based on interviews with key players in the initiative. We find that success occurred because the issue of spoofing was migrated away from the incentives of these companies into the incentive structures of the far more densely networked and centralised professional community of network engineers.

Richard Clayton: Richard is a software developer by trade and his software company wrote one of the first Internet access programs for Windows. In the mid-90s the company was sold to Demon Internet (AS2529), then the UK's largest ISP. At the turn of the century he went back to Cambridge to do a PhD and has stayed on as an academic "because it's much more fun than working". He was the founding director of the Cambridge Cybercrime Centre, making many and varied datasets related to cybercrime available to academics so they can concentrate on their research rather than learning the tedium of data collection at scale. Recently he has been advising law enforcement on ways to disrupt "booter" activity and to measure the impact of their actions.
Full Abstract

As part of this research, we demonstrate the surprising impact of 1% packet loss on throughput, both in symmetric and asymmetric networking topologies, in the environment using CUBIC congestion avoidance algorithm. Our findings reveal a significant decrease in throughput, more than 70%, compared to baseline measurements without packet loss. Moreover, we explore the effects of increasing packet loss levels, up to 10%, and observe a compounding decline in throughput, indicating the importance of addressing even minor levels of packet loss. We compare attained results using CUBIC congestion avoidance algorithm, in both topologies, with those achieved using the BBR congestion avoidance algorithm, advocating for broader and faster adoption of BBR.

Kemal Sanjta: Kemal is a result-oriented engineer focusing on designing, operating and troubleshooting large-scale networks. Passionate Linux user with a deep understanding of SRE/NRE practices. Over the last two decades, he worked at several large-scale companies applying NRE practices and automating remediation actions. As a Principal Internet Analyst at ThousandEyes, he focuses on research and providing deep and meaningful insights into outages through the lenses of ThousandEyes.
Full Abstract

BGP’s deployment model makes even modest software bugs have significant consequences on global Internet routing. 
When is a bug just a bug and not a security issue? 
CVSS is a scoring system used to classify issues and is an important input toward vendors issuing security alerts – and subsequently locking down all information on that issue. 
We discuss BGP and CVSS scoring and its impact upon the availability of information on BGP implementation defects.

Jeffrey Haas: Jeffrey Haas is a Distinguished Engineer at Juniper Networks where he works on the implementation and specification of BGP. Jeffrey is a Chair at the IETF IDR (inter-domain routing) Working Group where BGP is standardized. Additionally, in IETF, Jeffrey is a Chair for the BFD (bi-directional forwarding detection) Working Group. Jeffrey has been involved in working on Internet technologies since the late 90's where he worked at a small tier-3 ISP doing everything from helping people setup dial-up networking to helping maintain the company's Internet routing. Since then, he's worked at the NextHop startup that commercialized the GateD software; at Arbor Networks where he worked on routing, flow analytics, and management software; and most recently with Juniper. Jeffrey's day job is a mix of work on code, standards, and working with customers solving interesting problems. For fun, Jeffrey spends his off hours as an active participant in the Society for Creative Anachronism (SCA) and thoroughly enjoys a good, dark beer.
Full Abstract

This talk discusses methods and challenges involved in disrupting the operations of groups that carry out Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks. To disrupt DDoS attack operations, automated mechanisms need to continuously track global DDoS attacks and identify their orchestration infrastructures. This information enables sending high-quality takedown requests to hosting providers and domain registrars used by the DDoS groups. Successful takedown requests disrupt the attacks and demotivate DDoS operators by hampering their ability to keep their services running for financial gain. The takedown requests also help the recipient service providers to address gaps in their abuse detection and keep DDoS operations out of their platforms. However, these service providers respond to takedown requests at varying degrees of speeds and efficacy. The talk will explore alternative mechanisms to address these inconsistent responses.

Full Abstract

IPv6 has been "the next generation of IP" for over 20 years. For the longest time, the gold standard has been to run a network with both IPv4 and IPv6, however operating both protocols at the same time presents an additional operational challenge. With the global share of IPv6 traffic nearing 40-50%, it's time to re-evaluate our goal and look at ways to run networks that are largely IPv6-only. So how do we start testing IPv6-only technologies? They can be complex to setup and troubleshoot even for seasoned network engineers let alone application developers, IT support personnel, and others with limited networking experience.

Enter the IPv6 Test Pod, a device that intends to makes testing IPv6-only networks easy, made possible by the ARIN Community Grants program. The IPv6 Test Pod delivers a several IPv6-enabled networks, presented as SSIDs that the user can join to start testing IPv6-only technologies -- including dual-stack (as a baseline), IPv6-only, DNS64/NAT64, 464XLAT, and others. The IPv6 Test Pod is made available for no cost to project participants and participants can be anyone interested in testing IPv6-only networks including IT support personnel, developers, or even network engineers that are too busy to test IPv6-only networks. Dual stack is arriving, let's get ready for an IPv6-only world.

Full Abstract

This presentation will explore the integral role of the Number Resource Organization (NRO) and the Regional Internet Registries (RIRs) in global internet governance, with an emphasis on the new NRO RPKI Program, an initiative overseen by the NRO Executive Council. As a strategic effort under the NRO and RIRs, the RPKI Program is pivotal in advancing the development and adoption of Resource Public Key Infrastructure (RPKI) across the globe, enhancing the security and stability of internet routing. We will introduce the leadership team spearheading this program, outline our strategic objectives, and discuss the impactful initiatives that are currently being developed. The presentation will emphasize how this program is a collaborative effort guided by the expertise and governance of the NRO Executive Council, seeking to draw in active feedback from the technical community to refine and innovate our approach. Concluding with detailed resources and avenues for engagement, attendees will gain insights into the significance of their participation in shaping the future of internet security through the NRO RPKI Program.

Sofia Silva Berenguer: Program Manager, Process and Productivity Engineer, Ontological Coach and mum. Sofía holds an MSc in Telematics Engineering and is an Ontological Coach. She works as the RPKI Program Manager for the NRO and the Process and Productivity Engineer for the Registry Value Stream at APNIC. She joined the RIR world in 2010 when she started working for LACNIC as a Hostmaster and Policy Officer. She then held a few different technical roles at LACNIC, as a Networks and Security Engineer first, then moving on to a role as a Senior Security and Stability Specialist. She joined APNIC in 2017 as a Data Scientist, then became a Product Manager and later a Productivity Coach.

 

Join us for NANOG 89 in San Diego!

Registration fees increase as we get closer to the event. Register now and save!

Register Now!

 

Meeting Network Connectivity

att
Meraki
Juniper Networks

Network Lounge Sponsor

windstream wholesale

Espresso Bar Sponsor

Approved Networks

Beer 'n Gear Sponsors

Cisco
Infinera
IPv4.Global
Juniper Networks
kentik
LightRiver
Nesevo
Netscout
Nexusguard
Nokia
precision optical
Selector.ai

Peering Sponsors

DE-CIX
jpix

Sunday Night Social Host

mdc
Uniti

Monday Breakfast Sponsors

Cogent
Exaswitch
Exfo

Monday Lunch Sponsors

isc
qts
xkl

Monday Break Sponsors

Charter Communications
Choice IT Global
ntt

Monday Night Social Host

Towardex

Tuesday Breakfast Sponsor

Approved Networks
Corero
Exa Infrastructure

Tuesday Lunch Sponsors

BlueCat
Thousand Eyes
zpe

DEI Tuesday Lunch Sponsor

microsoft

Tuesday Break Sponsors

EdgeConneX
Myriad360
xkl

Tuesday Night Social Hosts

Arelion
Ciena
Crown Castle
Neutral Networks

Virtual Meeting Fellowships Sponsor

Image Description

Service Sponsors

AWS
Cloudflare
Container Lab
Deft